CIGNA Settlement Update
CIGNA Settlement Update - Claims Period Begins August 23

In April 2004, a federal appeals court upheld a $540 million settlement of the lawsuit between 700,000 physicians and CIGNA. As part of the settlement agreement, CIGNA recently announced a claims period for physicians to submit requests for payment. Eligible physicians will have from August 23, 2004 to February 18, 2005 to submit their claims. CIGNA plans to notify all physicians by mail.

Background
The CIGNA settlement stems from class action lawsuits brought by several medical societies against several national and regional managed care companies. Physicians argued that the health plans engaged in fraud and extortion in a common scheme to wrongfully deny payment to physicians. The lawsuits are scheduled to go to trial on September 13, 2004, but two of the defendants, Aetna and CIGNA, reached settlement agreements in 2003. As part of its settlement, CIGNA will pay physicians as many as 12 years of reimbursement dating back to 1990. More information about this settlement can be found at http://www.acc.org/pmr/resources/cigna_summ.htm.

Filing for Retrospective Relief from CIGNA
Physicians who wish to submit a claim with CIGNA for retrospective relief have several filing options. All forms and instructions for filing are available at www.hmosettlements.com and an explanation of this process is below.


Option 1 – Category A Settlement Fund

Physicians can seek compensation from the Category A Settlement Fund without submitting claims documentation. The Category A Settlement Fund is a $30 million pool of money that will be paid out on an aggregate basis. Physician payments will be calculated at the closing of the Claims Period and will be dependent upon the number of physicians who filed Category A claims. All payments from the Category A Settlement Fund will be made approximately two weeks after the Claims Period has ended.

To request Category A compensation, physicians must submit a Category A Proof of Claim Form by mail to the Settlement Administrator at the following address:

CIGNA Physician Settlement
Settlement Administrator
P.O. Box 3170
Portland, OR 97208-3170

Option 2 – Claim Distribution Fund

The Claim Distribution Fund is an uncapped settlement fund that requires physicians to submit proof that prior claims were improperly downcoded, bundled or denied based on medical necessity. The Claim Distribution Fund is divided into three categories:

Category One Compensation

Physicians who were denied payment or received reduced payments because of specific claim coding and bundling edits are eligible for Category One Compensation. For a list of code categories that qualify for Category One Compensation, click here. Codes listed without an asterisk require documentation showing that codes were submitted for reimbursement. Codes listed with an asterisk require documentation showing that the codes were submitted and that payment was denied or reduced. Acceptable documentation includes copies of HCFA 1500 forms, CMS 1500 forms, CIGNA Remittance forms, or internal accounting records.

Physicians who elect to submit claims for Category One Compensation must complete a Category One Compensation Proof of Claim form. Each request for payment must relate to a single episode of care, although it may seek compensation for multiple CPT codes. A separate cover sheet is attached to the Proof of Claim form and must precede each individual request for payment.

Category Two Compensation

Physicians who were denied payment or received reduced payments because of claim coding and bundling edits (other than those specified in Category One) are eligible for Category Two Compensation. CIGNA has compiled a list of claims that are eligible for Category Two Compensation, referred to as a Facilitation List. Physicians may obtain a Facilitation List specifically related to their claims by contacting the Settlement Administrator by e-mail or by calling 1-877-683-9363.

Physicians who elect to submit claims for Category Two Compensation must complete a Category Two Compensation Proof of Claim form. Each request for payment must relate to a single episode of care, although it may seek compensation for multiple CPT codes. A separate cover sheet is attached to the Proof of Claim form and must precede each individual request for payment. Supporting documentation is required, including a complete copy of the patient’s medical record. Acceptable documentation includes copies of HCFA 1500 forms, CMS 1500 forms, CIGNA Remittance forms, or internal accounting records.

Medical Necessity Denial Compensation

Physicians who believe that their claims were improperly denied as not medically necessary are eligible for Medical Necessity Denial Compensation.

Physicians who elect to submit claims for Medical Necessity Denial Compensation must fill out a Medical Necessity Denial Proof of Claim form. Each request for payment must relate to a single episode of care, although it may seek compensation for multiple CPT codes. A separate cover sheet is attached to the Proof of Claim form and must precede each individual request for payment. Supporting documentation is required, including a complete copy of required clinical information. Acceptable documentation includes copies of HCFA 1500 forms, CMS 1500 forms, CIGNA Remittance forms, or internal accounting records.

Please note: Physicians may seek compensation from either fund but not both.

All claims forms and appropriate documentation can be mailed to the Settlement Administrator at the following address:

CIGNA Physician Settlement
Settlement Administrator
P.O. Box 3170
Portland, OR 97208-3170

Physicians who are denied their request for payment will be notified by mail. Physicians will have 30 days to correct any deficiencies in the request for payment and resubmit the claim. Once approved, all payments from the Claim Distribution Fund will be made within approximately 30 days.

ACC is currently working with a claim auditing organization to provide assistance to members who are interested in pursuing retroactive reimbursement. More information will be made available once the claim period begins.

Back to Top | | Copyright © 2008 American College of Cardiology
Heart House | 2400 N Street, NW | Washington, DC 20037