Third Professional Life Survey Shows Changes in CV Workforce
Cardiologists Satisfied With Profession Overall, But Sex-Based Career Discrepancies Remain
Differences in career experiences between female and male cardiologists have lessened over the past 20 years; however, personal life choices and levels of discrimination continue to diverge significantly, according to a Council Perspective from ACC’s Women in Cardiology (WIC) Section published Dec. 21 in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology.
The third decennial Professional Life Survey, conducted by the Leadership Council of the WIC Section, found that career satisfaction remains high for both female and male cardiologists. Most respondents said they were satisfied with their financial compensation. Both genders reported that they would like to see more educational initiatives from the College regarding practice management issues such as job negotiations and leadership training.
Changes in the field of cardiology have affected both genders. “Dramatic changes have occurred in the practice patterns of cardiologists; fewer than a quarter now work in a private practice setting, down from almost three quarters of cardiologists 20 years ago,” said senior author Claire Duvernoy, MD, FACC, chair of the WIC Section. “Cardiologists have been aging; significantly greater numbers are over age 60 in the present survey than previously. Our profession must find ways to improve the pipeline of new cardiologists. To that end, we need to increase the diversity of our workforce, and find ways to recruit higher numbers of women, who currently number only 13 percent of the cardiology workforce, as well as underrepresented minorities.”
Despite experiencing the same career changes, female and male cardiologists reported substantial differences in their personal and professional experiences. “Men were much more likely to have children than women (87 percent vs. 72 percent),” said Sandra J. Lewis, MD, FACC, immediate past-chair of the WIC Section and first author of the paper. “For most of these men (57 percent), spouses provided all of the childcare. Female cardiologists with children at home were far more likely to pay for full- or part-time childcare, either in home or at a daycare center. Strikingly, 37 percent of women reported that family responsibilities had a negative impact on their career advancement, while only 20 percent of men reported the same."
“Men are increasingly balancing career and family,” stated the authors. “Women continue to be less likely to marry and to have children.” The majority of women who do marry have spouses who work full-time outside the home, creating a need for paid or unpaid childcare.
Discrimination remains a problem reported by a clear majority of female cardiologists – at a rate almost three times as frequently as men. “Sex and parenting discrimination was significantly more likely to have been experienced by women compared with men,” adds Lewis, while men were most likely to have experienced racial and religious discrimination. In a sign of possible progress, there was a decline in the number of women reporting discrimination overall between the first Professional Life Survey in 1996 and the 2015 survey (71 percent vs. 65 percent, respectively). “Women in cardiology continue to experience record rates of discrimination – 65 percent of women who responded to the survey reported experiencing some form of discrimination, as compared with 23 percent of men,” said Duvernoy. “We must work to change the culture that allows this to occur in our field.”
“With the third iteration of the Professional Life Survey, we now have data that provide us with 20 years of longitudinal information on the personal and professional lives of U.S. cardiologists – the largest study of its kind,” reflected Duvernoy. “These data reflect movement in the delivery of cardiology care, with subspecialization and employment models, but also underscore the failure of our profession to meet diversity challenges identified in the previous surveys.”
But these challenges won’t be met without the support of the entire cardiovascular community. "If half of all medical residents but only 13 percent of our cardiology community are women, we are missing the inclusion of some of the most talented young physicians,” said Lewis. “These data support an opportunity for cardiology leadership, both men and women, to assure that our future cardiologists represent the best and most inclusive group possible, free of discrimination in our community."
“The Professional Life Surveys conducted over the years have been invaluable in furthering our understanding of the concerns, values and experiences of cardiologists,” stated Mary Norine Walsh, MD, FACC, president-elect of the ACC and a co-author of the paper. “Important differences in experience between male and female cardiologists have emerged with each survey. This will be an important activity for the WIC Section Council to continue in the future to encourage the development of solutions with a focus on improving the lives of cardiologists.”
Clinical Topics: Acute Coronary Syndromes, Invasive Cardiovascular Angiography and Intervention, Noninvasive Imaging, Interventions and ACS, Interventions and Coronary Artery Disease, Interventions and Imaging, Angiography, Echocardiography/Ultrasound, Nuclear Imaging
Keywords: Acute Coronary Syndrome, American Heart Association, Angiography, Coronary Artery Disease, Decision Making, Echocardiography, Surgeons, Thoracic Surgery, Video-Assisted, Tomography, Cardiology Magazine, ACC Publications, ACC Scientific Session Newspaper
< Back to Listings