Burnout and Career Choice Regret Among US Resident Physicians

Study Questions:

How common are symptoms of burnout or career regret in US resident physicians in various specialties?

Methods:

A total of 3,588 students at 49 US allopathic medical schools completed surveys in the first and fourth years of medical school between 2010 and 2014 and in the second year of physician residency in 2016. The survey assessed demographics in year 1 of medical school; it evaluated USMLE Step 1 exam scores, educational debt, and psychometric scales of anxiety, empathy, and social support in year 4 of medical school. In the second year of residency, the survey reassessed demographics and assessed specialty choice, symptoms of burnout, and career and specialty regret.

Results:

Main study outcomes were symptoms of burnout and career and specialty regret.

Burnout symptoms were assessed using 2 single-item measures adapted from the Maslach Burnout Inventory previously shown to stratify burnout risk. Burnout symptoms were attributed to those who admitted to emotional exhaustion or depersonalization ≥once weekly.

  • Of all second-year residents, 45.2% reported ≥1 symptom of burnout at least weekly.
  • Internal medicine residents reported 42.6% prevalence of burnout. Internal medicine, the most common specialty, was utilized as the reference standard for comparison with other specialties.
  • Residents in urology (63.8%), neurology (61.6%), emergency medicine (53.8%), and general surgery (53.8%) were more likely than those in internal medicine to admit symptoms of burnout.
  • Residents in dermatology (29.6%) and pathology (34.7%) were less likely to admit symptoms of burnout.
  • Increased symptoms of burnout were associated with female sex (48.8%) and higher anxiety scores in year 4 of medical school; a decreased rate of burnout was associated with higher empathy scores in year 4 of medical school.

Career choice regret was expressed by residents who responded “definitely not” or “probably not” to the question “If you could revisit your career choice, would you choose to become a physician again?”

  • 14.1% of all residents and 12.2% of internal medicine residents expressed career choice regret.
  • Residents in pathology (32.7%) and anesthesiology (20.6%) were more likely to express career choice regret.
  • Burnout symptoms were strongly associated with career choice regret (23.0%, relative risk [RR] 3.20) after controlling for other factors.
  • Career choice regret was associated with higher anxiety scores in year 4 of medical school.

Specialty choice regret was expressed by residents who responded “definitely not” or “probably not” to the question “If you could revisit your specialty choice, would you choose the same specialty again?”

  • 7.1% of all residents and 10.6% of internal medicine residents expressed specialty choice regret.
  • Residents in anesthesiology, emergency medicine, family practice, pediatrics, psychiatry, ophthalmology, and orthopedic surgery were less likely to report specialty choice regret (range 3.3-6.0%).
  • Burnout symptoms were strongly associated with specialty choice regret (12.0%, RR 3.29) after controlling for other factors.
  • Increasing age was associated with specialty choice regret (RR 1.08 per 1 year older) after controlling for other factors. Factors associated with a lower risk of specialty choice regret included non-Hispanic ethnicity, higher empathy scores, and higher emotional social support scores.

Demographic characteristics were similar to those of all US resident physicians.

Conclusions:

Symptoms of burnout are highly prevalent in PGY2 US resident physicians (45.2%) and vary by specialty. Burnout symptoms are most prevalent among those training in urology, neurology, emergency medicine, or general surgery. Career regret and specialty choice regret are both strongly associated with burnout symptoms.

Perspective:

Prior studies of US physicians have demonstrated a high prevalence of burnout symptoms and substantial variability of burnout symptoms and career satisfaction by specialty. This survey of US physician residents may be the first national study, according to the authors, to demonstrate similar findings among physicians in training.

Clinical Topics: Prevention, Stress

Keywords: Schools, Medical, Internship and Residency, Physicians, Students, Burnout, Professional, Career Choice, Job Satisfaction, Anxiety, Depersonalization, Emotions, Empathy, Social Support, Risk, Psychometrics, Surveys and Questionnaires, United States


< Back to Listings