EMS Use by Persons With HF 2009-2017

Quick Takes

  • Heart failure (HF) patient education needs to include self-management of chest pain and shortness of breath and when to activate emergency medical services (EMS).
  • Research on the pre-hospital context is needed to more fully address EMS use among community dwellers with chronic HF.

Study Questions:

What are the predictors of EMS use, including multiple EMS transports over an 8-year period, among community-dwelling adults living with HF?

Methods:

An analysis of electronic health records data from a single, large urban Midwestern county EMS program was conducted to characterize the clinical status of and treatments and medications administered to adults with self-reported HF who were transported by EMS from home to 1 of 3 medical centers over an 8-year period (2009-2017) in order to evaluate predictors of EMS use and multiple EMS transports. Predictor variables of mortality in previous studies were assessed at the index EMS transport, including 1) blood pressure, 2) heart rate, 3) oxygen saturation, 4) decreased level of consciousness, 5) shortness of breath, and 6) chest pain. Chi-square and t-tests were conducted to examine differences between adults with 1 transport and those with multiple transports. Logistic regression was used to model significant univariate variables as independent predictor variables of multiple transports (i.e., 1 versus more than 1).

Results:

Over the 8-year study period, a total of 16,905 EMS transports (range = 1-80; median = 2) was made for the 6,582 adults with reported HF; the majority of multiple transports (i.e., 5-80) were made for 795 adults (12.1%). Adults were mostly women (57.6%) and Black (57.7%) and were on average 63.7 ± 14.5 years of age. Chief complaints across all transports were respiratory problems (26.6%), feeling sick (23%), and chest pain (17%). During transports, 38,079 treatments were administered, including administering medications (37.1%), establishing intravenous/intraosseous access (23.2%), administering oxygen (20.8%), and delivering intravenous fluid (11.4%). The most frequently administered medications were nitroglycerin (26.9%), albuterol (23%), aspirin (16.5%), ipratropium bromide (15.9%), ondansetron (5.8%), and fentanyl (4.8%). Among the selected a priori predictor variables, shortness of breath, chest pain, and low level of consciousness (low Glascow Coma Scale scores) were associated with greater odds of having multiple transports. Co-variates significantly associated with greater odds of having multiple EMS transports were age, gender, race, and hospital site; adults of younger age, female gender, and Black race were more likely to have multiple transports. In this study, significant predictors of multiple EMS transports include shortness of breath, chest pain, and increased oxygen saturation. For instance, adults who had shortness of breath during the index EMS transport had 13.1% more transports compared with adults who were otherwise similar. Age, gender, and hospital site were significant co-variates associated with multiple EMS transports.

Conclusions:

Investigators evaluated predictors of multiple EMS transports from home to hospital among persons with HF living in a large, urban Midwestern county. Prevalent symptoms in this study parallel those in the literature. Chest pain was the most frequently reported clinical status variable at the index transport and was documented for nearly two-thirds (65%) of the adults. Collectively, findings provide insights into reasons persons living with HF are transported by EMS and serve as hypothesis-generating for further study and understanding of EMS use.

Perspective:

Symptom burden and risk for hospitalization are high in adults living with HF. Understanding the pre-hospital context in which symptoms occur is important for developing and testing interventions that will effectively address potentially preventable use of EMS and enhance self-care symptom management.

Clinical Topics: Heart Failure and Cardiomyopathies, Acute Heart Failure

Keywords: Heart Failure, Emergency Medical Services, Ambulances, Electronic Health Records, Self Report, Independent Living, Self Care, Chest Pain, Dyspnea


< Back to Listings